Ziff Davis EnterpriseDevLife
Advertisement

Wednesday, February 13, 2008 8:33 AM/EST

Dell's Tablet PC next to Lenovo Thinkpad Tablet

A marketing email this morning reminded me that I had meant to talk a little about the fact that Dell is finally manufacturing (or at least putting their name on) a Tablet PC. It's a Tablet version of their mid-range Latitude laptop - the Latitude XT. (The order of Dell's laptops is (low-end) Vostro, Latitude, Precision, XPS (extreme performance). It looks like they targeted the Lenovo Thinkpad tablets with most of their specs.

I haven't found any side by side comparison, but since I don't have the Dell (though I do have the Lenovo) I'll use their online specs to compare the options. (Lenovo's spec sheet, Dell's spec sheet)

Feature Dell Lenovo
Processor Options Intel Core Solo 1.02 or Intel Core Duo 1.2 Intel Core Duo 1.6 or Intel Core Duo 1.8
Display 12.1 MultiTouch (the outdoor version doesn't seem to mean losing the multitouch)(1280x800) 12.1 XGA MutliView (1024x768 max) and MultiTouch OR 12.1 SXGA (better for outdoors) w/UltraConnect Antenna (1400x1050 max)
Drive Options 40 or 80 GB 4200 RPM, 120 GB 5400RPM 80 - 200 GB drives with 5400 to 7200 rpm
Blue Tooth Optional Optional
Wireless Options WiFi built in, WWAN optional WiFi built in , WWAN optional
Battery 4 & 6 cell options 4 & 8 Cell options
Optical Drive optional but also requires a media base optional but also requires a media base
Starting Weight 3.6lbs 3.8 lbs
Starting Price $2500 $1500
Max RAM 3GB (I'm not sure of this, it's the most I see offered, but I didn't see any "max" spec) 4GB plus "Intel Turbo Memory" that looks similar to Vista's memory boost

So, while they look comparable, it is possible to create a much higher-end rig with the Lenovo than you can with the Dell. The Dell's "entry" configuration is already $1000 more and a lot whimpier than Lenovo's.

I know that one of the big problems with Tablets early on was that there were not enough low-priced entry level machines for the average user who does not need a lot of performance. There are now a number of options in that range, but at $2500, Dell isn't going to even touch that market. And I think that people looking for more performance will get more bang for their buck with the Lenovo. One downside I find with my Lenovo is the limited resolution - I have the multi touch so I get 1024x768 max which is a real drag when I'm using Visual Studio because I don't have a lot of screen real estate to leverage. It's even more of a problem when I'm doing conference presentations and demoing in Visual Studio. I could have opted out of the multi-touch and gone for the 1400x1050, but I really like the multi-touch. Of all of the tablets I have had, the Toshiba was always the hands down winner when it came to screen resolution. So Dell does have that advantage of having the multi-touch with a decent 1280x800.

TrackBack

TrackBack

http://blogs.devsource.com/cgi-bin/mte/mt-tb.cgi/12707

Comments (2)

Julia Lerman :

Bill, I could tease you and feign surprise that there are other Tablets, but of course I know that. I was curious how it compares to the tablet that I own.

Post a Comment

 
 

Advertisement

Syndication

Subscribe: